What does this calculator do?
This calculator puts two fixed-rate loan offers for the same amount side by side: monthly payment, total repayment including any upfront fee, and the difference between them. It presents the mathematical comparison only — which trade-off suits you (lower payment vs lower total cost) is your decision.
Formula
Each offer uses the standard amortization formula, monthly payments:
Payment = P × [r(1+r)^n] / [(1+r)^n − 1] total = payment × n + fee
How to use it
Enter the amount once, then each offer’s rate, term and optional upfront fee. A negative difference means offer B costs less in total; note that a longer term often lowers the payment while raising the total cost.
Worked example
15,000: offer A at 6% for 5 years pays 289.99/month, ≈17,400 total. Offer B at 5.5% for 6 years with a 300 fee pays 245.06/month but ≈17,944 total — B is cheaper monthly yet ≈545 more expensive overall.
Frequently asked questions
Which offer should I choose?
This tool deliberately does not recommend — it shows the math. Lower total cost and lower monthly payment often conflict; regulated APR figures from the lenders capture costs this comparison leaves out.
Why compare totals including fees?
A lower rate with a high upfront fee can cost more overall than a slightly higher rate without one. Totals make that visible.
Can the terms be different lengths?
Yes — that is the most common real comparison. Just remember a longer term means paying interest for longer even at a lower rate.
Sources
- OpenStax — Principles of Finance (loan amortization and level-payment annuities); the formula is shown on every page.
- U.S. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — how loan payments are determined (government consumer-finance education)
- Reviewed: 2026-07-30
Related calculators
Last updated: 2026-07-30 · v1.0.0 · Report an error